Restless for Good Art


Why are Catholic movies so bad? Historically the Church has been patron to some of mankind’s greatest artists; from the Sistine Chapel to medieval mystery plays, Catholicism has been a wellspring for the arts, both elite and popular. So why is it that “good Christian movie” is almost a contradiction in terms?

We can learn a lot about the problems of Catholic filmmaking from Christian Duguay’s new film Restless Heart, a dramatized account of St. Augustine’s life and conversion. As a film, Restless Heart has its high points, even if in general it suffers from poor pacing and uninspiring dialogue. As a biography of a great theologian, the film fares worse; recognizing the difficulties in staging most of Augustine’s life (How does one film a gradual conversion from Skepticism to Neo-platonism?), Restless Heart blithely invents a more exciting history for him, turning the troubled young professor of rhetoric into a hotshot lawyer with a devil-may-care attitude who, after cooperating in a massacre of Milanese Christians, miraculously converts and triumphs over all his adversaries, notably including a scene in which all the heretical Donatist bishops in North Africa agree that the Roman Church has the true faith, and seal their conversion with group hugs.

If we abstract from the religious character of the film, we can easily understand why Restless Heart is unlikely to win any Academy Awards; whatever its other problems, it ultimately fails to entertain. Viewed from a Christian perspective, the occasional moments of real drama don’t justify vitiating one of Christianity’s most compelling conversion stories and replacing it with a boilerplate fourth-century knock-off of a John Grisham novel.

So what went wrong? Behind the problem of entertainment lies a deeper one: a problem of art. Self-consciously Catholic films, from Bella to For Greater Glory to Restless Heart, tend to misunderstand the nature of art and its relationship to Christianity. These films seem to begin with Christianity as an architectural frame, then clap on some interchangeable story as drywall, resulting in a completed film that feels as original and creative as a suburban McMansion.

Real art works differently. The artist plunges himself into the stuff of the world and grabs hold of some one reality that he can’t let go; he then lifts it out from the undifferentiated morass of his experience and contemplates it in the light of all he knows. Artistic creation occurs when he gives his encounter with that reality a form that allows it to speak to others—be it the composition of a painting, the plot of a novel, or the narrative of a movie.

When this encounter is genuine and its artistic expression is lucid, the viewer is led to experience a new dimension of the world around him, to see afresh some facet of the truth. Because God is himself Truth, the artistic encounter with the world’s truth is, while not itself a religious event, inherently open to being elevated by grace. But art becomes truly religious when the reality the artist expresses acts as a prism for some facet of the Divine Truth; then to understand the work of art is to be open to the God whose beauty it refracts into human symbols.

If this is the dynamic of art—reaching into reality, being changed by it, and revealing that transformative truth to others—then we can understand why books, films, or paintings that only serve as a vehicle for spreading an idea fail as art. Formally speaking, they are more akin to propaganda, even if they use the material of art. Writing a song because I want more people to buy my brand of toothpaste may be a valuable commercial move, but it is not art. Making a movie because I want more people to acknowledge St. Augustine as the greatest doctor of the Latin Church may be laudable catechesis, but it won’t turn into art.

But making art as a Christian is not easy, especially in an art world that is dominated by worldviews opposed to the message of Jesus Christ. There’s a strong natural temptation to believe that unless my art boldly proclaims my beliefs in a straightforward way, I am somehow failing the New Evangelization and squandering my talent.

The solution to that problem is complex and difficult—William Congdon said that figuring out how to make art again after his conversion nearly drove him insane—but it must begin by acknowledging the connection between the truth of art and the Truth of God. These are not two radically separate things; the Christian artist who allows himself to be changed by the deepest truths of reality will speak of God when he speaks of what he saw, even if he is painting cows in a field.

The artist—any artist—must begin with what changes him, not with an abstract idea. If God changes him through some thing in the world, then speaking of that thing will allow the artist to speak of God. The would-be artist who starts with an idea or a message is doomed to failure. The artist who starts with God’s movement in his life may find that he has found true art by following his restless heart.

Image: James Tissot, Self-Portrait

You May Also Enjoy:

“Hakuna Matata” and the Philosophy of Unwillingn... Hakuna Matata. This famous phrase from the '90s Disney movie The Lion King is more than the theme of a catchy tune sung by a lion, a warthog, and a meerkat; it's a philosophy on living that pervades the modern world. Its basic tenets come from understanding that bad things happen and that there is nothing you can do about them. In acknowledging this, the solution is to turn inward, seek one's own ideal life, and forget about all the problems arou...
A Hermit’s Courage In the film Jeremiah Johnson, a veteran of the Mexican-American War decides to begin his life anew on the American frontier, braving the elements as a real mountain man. What’s interesting is that in many ways his story parallels that of St. Antony of the Desert, the fourth-century founder of monasticism. Things don’t begin easily for Jeremiah Johnson. This ex-soldier’s first season of trapping and hunting yields meager results, and his first ...
Is Nice a Vice? Michael Bluth, the main character of the cult TV series Arrested Development, is the consummate nice guy. With his sheepishly tousled hair, disarming smile, devoted work ethic, and commitment to family, he is the one member of the chaotic Bluth family who consistently tries to do the right thing. But somehow Michael’s nice-guyness often leads him away from the straight and narrow, wandering among bramblesome deeds like lies, theft, and philanderi...
The God of Bigfoot It’s high time we talked about Bigfoot. In case you haven’t been paying attention, Bigfoot is big news. Animal Planet’s Finding Bigfoot, a reality-TV show that follows the efforts of a committed team of Bigfoot researchers on their scientific quest, is going to start its highly anticipated fourth season in November; the premiere of the third season garnered 1.3 million viewers. Informal dabblers in Bigfoot studies can explore innumerable websites...
Br. Gabriel Torretta, O.P.

Written by:

Br. Gabriel Torretta entered the Order of Preachers in 2008. He studied pre-modern Japanese literature at Columbia University. On