The Black Friday War

In ancient and medieval philosophy, all ethics came back to a fundamental question, “What is happiness?”  The answer to this question was turned on its head in most modern philosophy.  I suspect that our implicit worldview about happiness has become something like the characteristically modern view which Thomas Hobbes describes in this passage from Leviathan.

“The felicity of this life consisteth not in the repose of a mind satisfied.  For there is no such Finis ultimus (utmost aim) nor Summum Bonum (greatest good) as is spoken of in the books of the old moral philosophers.  Nor can a man any more live, whose desires are at an end… Felicity is a continual progress of desire, from one object to another, the attaining of the former being still but the way to the latter.”

The true radicality of this claim is shocking.  All moral philosophers hitherto had thought that happiness involved the resting of the will in the acquisition of a good.  Hobbes flatly denies that the “rest” of the will makes any sense.  He can only interpret happiness (“felicity”) as being the continual “procurement” of thing after thing.  All men have within themselves a “perpetual and restless desire of power after power,” and happiness means giving that desire room to roam.

We might profitably consider whether this is the “Black Friday” philosophy.  Consumerism tends to direct us to the acquiring of an endless sequence of goods.  Advertisement goads us toward new desires.  The good is desired, appropriated, consumed and discarded—so that one can desire, appropriate and consume yet more.

St. Augustine, of course, had diagnosed this problem over a millennium before Hobbes.  He knew that the endless and restless pursuit of imperfect worldly goods causes weariness and lassitude—boredom.  That restless pursuit is more likely to throw us into an existential malaise (a la Walker Percy’s Moviegoer) than actually to fulfill us.  In selfishly searching for finite goods, we really choose ourselves as our own last end.  In doing so, it is no wonder that we become so stuffed full of ourselves that we end in disgust and not happiness.

This is why Augustine says, “You have made us for Yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in You.” No matter how many partial goods we aggregate, or sequentially dominate, we will never be happy.  Our will wants an infinite good, not infinite goods. What we want is peace—rest in the Good.

Now, even if you’ve just returned from the biggest sale ever, a Hobbesian “perpetual war of all against all,” don’t worry about your eternal soul. I’m not saying that everyone who shops today is going to hell.  This is just a reminder that finite goods, even finite goods sold at fantastic discounts, can’t solve the problems that other finite goods can’t fill, and that we should be vigilant that we don’t try to make them do things they can’t do.  And if we do find ourselves bored, empty, or depressed this shopping season, the antidote might be recommitting ourselves to the pursuit of the one, true good: God. In Him we may have a foretaste of that endless spiritual joy in which no man can be bored. St. Augustine gives us a beautiful prayer to use in times like this:

“Lord God, give us peace—for you have granted us all things—the peace of quiet, the peace of the Sabbath which has no evening… the seventh day is without evening.  The sun does not set on it, because you sanctified it to last forever.  For after all your works which were very good, you rested on the seventh day, although you made all these works in an unbroken rest.  So may the voice of your book tell us in advance that we too, after our works… may rest in you in the Sabbath of eternal life.”

Image: Andy Warhol, Dollar Sign

You May Also Enjoy:

Holy Dissatisfaction The other evening a brother and I were chatting about the various songs and musicians that we have appreciated over the years. To our surprise, we discovered that we have similar musical tastes, and so the conversation had a certain air of shared nostalgia about it that was quite enjoyable. One of the things that struck us both is how, since we entered religious life, our use of music for entertainment and relaxation has changed dramatically. ...
Providence and Pigskins Last week veteran NFL quarterback Fran Tarkenton wrote an article in the Wall Street Journal in which he mused on the intersection of faith and football. A religious man himself ("charismatic before charismatic was cool," he says), Mr. Tarkenton raises some questions that not only have serious weight for football fans, but also provide an occasion for genuine theological reflection. "Does God care who wins football games?" he asks. Is which team ...
A Religion Beyond Appearances In the early twentieth century, certain religious reactions to the hyper-rationalism of the Enlightenment attempted to place religion out of reach of scientism and determinism. The twentieth-century German theologian Rudolf Otto described religiosity as a ‘feeling of the numinous,’ meaning an encounter with ‘the holy’ which transcended reason in every way, and yet was undeniable in its reality. ‘The holy’ here is experienced as an overpowering my...
More than Miraculous When people think of miracles, an image of “wonder-works” comes to mind that ranges from the magnificent to the superstitious. But how tenable are miracles? Do they really happen, and, if so, can we believe in them? In a 2009 debate Christopher Hitchens put forward the following claim: “I would say… faced with a supposed miracle, that it is much more likely that I am under a misapprehension than I am actually witnessing a miracle, and so would...
Br. John Sica, O.P.

Written by:

Fr. John Sica was ordained to the priesthood in May 2016. He was born and raised on Long Island, NY. He attended Providence College, where he met the Dominican friars. After graduating in 2010 with a Bachelor's in philosophy, he joined the Dominican Order. He made solemn vows in August 2014. On DominicanFriars.org